The Masks And Mysteries Of Halloween 4: Part I




Halloween 4: The Return Of Michael Myers marked the return of the malevolent stalker after Halloween III: Season Of The Witch failed to change the course of the series. With the success of celluloid slasher icons Freddy Krueger and Jason Voorhees, Myers was pulled out of his fiery retirement and Halloween 4 became a success. However, twenty four years after its release, fans are still confused and mystified by the varying masks that appear throughout the film. Arguably, Halloween 4 is the last entry in the series to feature a mask based on William Shatner’s likeness, although it looks wildly different than the masks used on the first two Halloween films. Many fans of the series are eager to understand where the mask came from, why there are various differences in it throughout the film, and how many masks appear.

The story goes that there was an unconverted Captain Kirk ’75 left over from Halloween II which the makers of Halloween 4 acquired and began filming with. However, someone noticed that the Myers mask didn’t have blonde hair and a tan, and somewhere along the way it became converted to resemble the mask from the first two films. However, the Halloween 4 hero mask shares strong similarities in features to the Don Post Myers masks of the mid Eighties and is possibly a re-cast of a previous mask, whether that be a Captain Kirk or ‘The Mask’, the name given to licensed Myers masks. Whilst I (or seemingly anyone for that matter) can’t offer any real answers, I will look at the most strikingly different/unusual variations of masks seen in the film and try to make some sense of the mysteries surrounding them.


The most commonly used mask in the film is of course the ‘hero’ mask, hence its name. However, even this undergoes some changes over time, both in the film and in the real world. In some scenes, most notably the death of Brady, the eyeholes are quite small (left). Stuntman George P. Wilbur who portrays the Shape in both this and Halloween: The Curse Of Michael Myers says that they hindered his vision, something essential not only for acting but for performing the action scenes and stunts required of him, so he took a pair of scissors to the eyeholes and made them larger (centre). Over time the mask has obviously shown signs of ageing (image by user crofader, right), and with this comes some confusion. As the white paint flakes away and the colour comes out of the hair, it’s clear to see the mask was originally skintone and the hair was originally platinum blonde. However, the ‘hero’ doesn’t have the features of a ’75 Kirk, which seems to contradict the story told by Ken Horn, who was interviewed by Gorezone about the film. In the interview he apparently said that the unconverted Captain Kirk left over from Halloween II was recast and many were made. The neck extension visible in the centre picture was apparently added due to the shrinking of the recasts, although another story is that the recasts were larger than the Kirk to accomodate George P. Wilbur’s head shape. As you can see, multiple stories and contradictions make finding out the truth near impossible. Danielle Harris, child star of Halloween 4 and Halloween 5: The Return Of Michael Myers, has also apparently said that a mask originally had a flesh tone and platinum blonde hair and was often spray painted. 

The most notable of variations in Halloween 4, this mask bears a skin tone similar to the ’75 Kirk, and platinum blonde hair. At first glance, especially with the small eyeholes, it is easy to say that this is a ’75 Captain Kirk. Whilst the mask has strong Kirk features and evokes both a Castle and Warlock vibe when worn, the ears are notably different to a Kirk and more akin to an early-to-mid Eighties ‘The Mask’. The ’75 Kirk had larger ears than ‘The Mask’ which has smaller ears. Again, it’s too difficult to explain where the mask came from or if it’s the hero before conversion. Another story floating around the internet ether is that Don Post Studios made masks for Halloween II, which could explain both its unique combination of Kirk and ‘The Mask’, as well as it coming from the set of Halloween II. The story behind its inclusion is that the schoolhouse scene where the mask appears was too expensive to reshoot entirely, so the unconverted mask had to remain in the film.

Used when Michael thrusts a shotgun through Sheriff Meeker’s daughter Kelly, this mask seems markedly different from the hero, although lighting is at play here. It shares a similar shape to the unconverted mask, as well as seemingly identical hair, although certain features seem to remove the possibility of it being a Kirk. Along with the ears, the eyebrows are quite different to those sculpted onto a ’75 Kirk, and are more akin to the sad/surprised eyebrows of the hero and seem almost identical to the very rare Don Post 1984 ‘The Mask’. Its facial features are also similar to the ’84 and it certainly evokes a more Castle-Warlock vibe than the hero.

As you can see, there’s no easy route to the origins behind the masks used in Halloween 4, and until someone steps forward to let the fans in on the truth, all we can do is speculate.

Stay tuned for Part II, where we look at the Discount Mart masks, a stunt mask and the poster art mask!

13 thoughts on “The Masks And Mysteries Of Halloween 4: Part I”

  1. l33tmyers says:

    Great article,Ive always wondered about the Halloween 4 masks myself,stil so much mystery behind the masks.

  2. Ian Laidlaw says:

    how come they need so much masks in one movie though.

    1. probably to get a certain look in certain scenes but nobody knows it is unusual though

  3. theshapeoffear says:

    It shows you how some people in hollywood are totally out of touch sometimes and why sequels are so brutal sometimes….dont get me wrong, i enjoy this movie, but it blows my mind that they actually filmed some scenes with a flesh toned blond haired Kirk mask before someone clued in that the Myers mask isnt suppose to be that color..brutal!!

  4. wtrailer says:

    This is definitely the beginning of the end of the series for me. The mask(s) are just all around bad. I like to compare this Myers to a guy working a haunted house – Has a white mask and coveralls but looks nothing like the Shape. Nothing about Wilbur’s performance seemed right. He was just a generic version of a classic character. More of a post-Jason Myers, with the beefed up shoulders and all. We don’t even get a glimmer of the character portrayed by Castle/Warlock. I can go on and on about how much I hate this film ; ) I am still wondering if there is any way I could get my money back for false advertising. The poster art and title clearly showed Michael Myers was in the film but he was nowhere to be seen.

  5. brandon says:

    I’ve read a lot of good things on the front page of this website but this is by far my favorite article!

  6. jdash10 says:

    Wow Brandon, that means a lot!

  7. The mask with blonde/platinum hair was only used in that one scene in Halloween 4 when Michael attacked Loomis in the High School (at night with the alarm ringing loud) and it always bothered me. It's such an obvious difference and in no other part of the film does the mask look remotely close to that one. I'm glad that people noticed it.

  8. in my opinion halloween 4 : the return of michael myers masks are the worst of the original franchise

    [Editor: For me, it’s the mask from Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers. The only aspects that are Michael Myers-ish about that mask are that it’s white, it has hair, and it has humanoid facial features.]

  9. kolbyray86 says:

    does anyone know where i can purchase a legit hero mask from part 4? dear god i want one so bad!

  10. Ryan says:

    I agree…I love this mask! It’s so totally different from the H1/H2 mask…yet oddly similar. I’m also nostalgic because I can remember watching this one the most when I was a kid…seems like our local UPN would show this one every Halloween:)

  11. Lydia Davis says:

    the mask with blonde hair looked like the mask ben tramer used in halloween 2

  12. I figured out a way to recapture the look of the “Blonde”mask in h4 all you need is a pair of h4 coveralls and a captain Kirk or ben tramer mask

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *